“C’mon, let’s do it again!” (New York Times)

The Rocky Horror Show made a high-voltage return to Broadway last night, officially opening at Studio 54 to an explosion of acclaim from leading critics who praised the production’s energy, cast, and thrilling sense of event. The Roundabout Theatre Company revival, directed by Tony Award winner Sam Pinkleton, was widely recognized as a bold, joyful reimagining of the cult classic—one that leans confidently into both theatrical spectacle and subversive fun.

Leading the critical conversation, The New York Times named the production a Critic’s Pick, applauding its refusal to be overly reverent and celebrating the electric unpredictability that defines Rocky Horror. The review highlighted the production’s dynamic relationship with its audience, noting that the show’s power lies in its ability to teeter thrillingly on the edge of control—making every performance feel alive and immediate.

“It’s an awfully hard one to resist” (Time Out New York)

“The halls of Studio 54 should be proud with the glittery whirlwind happening on stage eight times a week” (Theatrely)

Much of the praise centred on the starry cast, led by Luke Evans as Dr. Frank-N-Furter. Critics widely agreed that Evans commands the stage with charisma, confidence, and vocal power, delivering a performance that is both playful and commanding. Several outlets singled out his star presence as a key driver of the show’s infectious momentum.

“Ok, so maybe the times haven’t changed all that much. More’s the reason we need a little jump to the left and a step to the right and, most of all, a pelvic thrust that really drives you insaaa-yaa-yaane” (Deadline)

Time Out New York awarded the production four stars, calling it “deliciously warped and timely” and praising its exuberant theatricality. The review emphasized the immersive design of Studio 54—whose own storied history of decadence adds an extra layer of meaning—and applauded the production for transforming the theatre into a fully realized world that extends beyond the stage.

“There’s no other way to describe it but to say… it’s astounding.” (New York Theatre Guide)

Publications including amNewYork celebrated the production as pure theatrical escapism, describing it as an entertaining, high-end party that embraces camp, queerness, and spectacle with confidence. The venue choice of Studio 54 was repeatedly cited as inspired, with critics noting that few Broadway houses feel as thematically aligned with Rocky Horror’s glam-rock DNA.

“For nearly two hours, it delivers what it promises: a weird, exuberant, and thoroughly enjoyable night out. Participation optional, temptation unavoidable.” (AM New York)

Across the board, opening-night reviews agreed on one thing: The Rocky Horror Show has arrived not just as a revival, but as a full-scale Broadway event. With its sold-out energy, critic’s accolades, and a cast clearly relishing every beat, the production has firmly established itself as one of the most talked-about openings of the season. As audiences continue to flock to Studio 54, this latest incarnation proves that Rocky Horror still knows exactly how to thrill, provoke, and delight—night after night.

Photography: Joan Marcus